In the tangled web of global connectivity, where perceptions dance to the tune of media orchestrations, it's a familiar sight to witness misconceptions and objections swirling around the rights of women in Islam. Western narratives often paint Islam as a suppressor of women's liberties, spotlighting grievances about testimony, education, economic rights, and even throwing in a dash of violence for dramatic effect. The prevailing story whispers tales of hijab-clad oppression, branding Islam as an autocrat over women, leaving the nuanced reality obscured in the shadows of biased storytelling.
Addressing Misconceptions: Women's Rights in Islam
In the realm of narrow perspectives, some may ask, "Does a woman's sole purpose boil down to birthing offspring and crafting culinary delights?" Yet, let's unmask the absurdity in this line of thinking. Is a man condemned to be a mere currency minting machine or a bodyguard in perpetual armor? Similarly, are kids destined to be imprisoned in a cycle of relentless studying and grade-chasing? The rhetoric echoes across all fronts – an attempt to confine the limitless essence of human potential within the shackles of simplistic assumptions. Break free from these cages of stereotypes, for in the vast canvas of existence, roles are as diverse as the colors in a wild painting.
In navigating the discourse around women's rights in Islam, it's essential to address common objections that have been raised. Let's clarify these concerns and shed light on the empowering principles that underlie the role of women in Islam.
Objection 1. Hijab and Dress Code: Critics argue that the requirement for women to wear the hijab (headscarf) or observe modest dress is oppressive and limits their personal freedom.
In the vibrant tapestry of Islamic principles, the hijab stands not just as fabric, but as a divine decree, woven into the essence of a woman's identity by the Almighty Himself. It's not a mere piece of cloth; it's a symbol of empowerment, a beacon of strength, and a shield of dignity.
Imagine this: A modern-day princess, donning her hijab like a crown, exuding confidence and grace. This isn't about stifling freedom; it's about owning it. The hijab isn't a restriction; it's a statement—a statement that says, "I control my narrative, my worth, and my beauty."
It's not about hiding; it's about revealing what truly matters. The hijab isn't a barrier; it's a bridge—a bridge between a woman's inner strength and the outer world. It's a fortress, protecting her from the noise of objectification and the pressure to conform to shallow standards of beauty.
In a world obsessed with appearances, the hijab is a reminder that true beauty lies in character, resilience, and self-respect. It's a symbol of defiance against a culture that reduces women to objects of desire, reminding us that a woman's worth is not measured by the length of her skirt or the tightness of her clothes.
Let's be crystal clear The hijab isn't just a piece of fabric; it's a symbol of empowerment, a celebration of diversity, and a testament to the strength of the human spirit. It's a reminder that you have the power to define yourself on your own terms, unapologetically and boldly
Quranic and Hadith Wisdom:
a. Quranic Elegance (24:31): "And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof..." This verse is a lyrical ode to modesty, inspiring the concept of the hijab as a shield against the gaze that disrespects.
b. Hadith Resonance: In the echo of Hadith, the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) proclaimed, "Modesty is part of faith" (Sahih Al-Bukhari). It's a timeless reminder that modesty is not just a garment; it's an integral part of one's faith.
Objection no.2
Polygamy: The permissibility of polygamy in Islam is a subject of debate. Some believe it is unfair to women and can lead to unequal treatment.
Polygamy in Islam, often a subject of controversy, is intricately intertwined with socio-economic considerations and the compassionate ethos of the religion. It's not merely a matter of personal choice but a response to societal needs, addressing situations where women may find themselves widowed, families shattered, or individuals struggling to survive in challenging circumstances.
Consider a woman who, due to the tragic demise of her husband, finds herself in a state of widowhood. In many societies, cultural norms might dictate that she abstain from remarriage. However, Islam takes a pragmatic approach, recognizing the emotional and social needs of individuals. The option of polygamy emerges not as a whimsical desire but as a structured solution.
In scenarios where families are decimated, leaving only one surviving member, the burden of supporting and caring for that individual falls upon the broader community. Polygamy, within its Islamic framework, becomes a means of social responsibility, with a man taking on the mantle of supporting up to four women, preventing them from falling into destitution or orphanhood.
Crucially, the principles guiding polygamy in Islam ensure that favoritism is strictly prohibited. A husband is obligated to treat each wife with equality, both in terms of material provisions and emotional considerations. The Quran's insistence on equitable treatment among wives (4:3) isn't a mere suggestion; it's a non-negotiable condition. Each wife is entitled to her separate dwelling, ensuring her individual space and domain. This structured approach aims to foster harmony within the family unit.
Acknowledging the complexity of marriage, Open and honest communication among all parties is vital to address concerns, resolve conflicts, and maintain trust and emotional well-being.
Quranic and Hadith References:
a. Quranic Verse (4:3): "And if you fear that you will not deal justly with the orphan girls, then marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one..."
This verse emphasizes the importance of treating all wives with equity and fairness in polygamous marriages.
b. Hadith: The Hadith literature contains numerous reports highlighting the importance of equitable treatment in polygamous marriages. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is reported to have said, "Whoever has two wives and inclines more to one of them, he will come on the Day of Resurrection with half of his body leaning" (Sunan Abi Dawud).
Objection no. 3
Inheritance: Inheritance laws in Islam, which often allocate smaller shares to women compared to men, are criticized as unequal.
Let's understand it with few Assertion:
Provider and Protector Role: In Islam, men are designated as the providers and protectors of women within the intricate fabric of familial dynamics. This responsibility encompasses not only financial aspects but extends to emotional and physical protection. The Quran underscores this role, making men accountable for their mothers, sisters, daughters, and wives.
Financial Responsibilities: The financial discrepancy in inheritance aligns with the distinctive roles prescribed. Men receive a larger share not as a testament to superiority but as a means to fulfill their multifaceted financial responsibilities. This division acknowledges the financial burden placed on men to sustain their families.
Inheritance and Financial Freedom: Women, receiving half in inheritance, aren't financially shortchanged; rather, they gain financial autonomy. Unencumbered by financial responsibilities for others, they have the liberty to utilize their wealth as they see fit. In contrast, men, bestowed with more significant shares, shoulder the financial welfare of their entire family.
Property Rights and Marriage: The system ensures equity. A woman not only inherits but also has rights over her husband's property. This dual entitlement safeguards her financial interests. In marriage, her financial portfolio expands, merging the inheritance from her parents with the shared assets of her husband. This unique structure ensures financial security without the burden of supporting others.
Independent Earnings: A woman's earnings are exclusively hers, and no one can stake a claim. She has the freedom to spend as she pleases, unburdened by familial financial obligations. In stark contrast, a man's earnings come with the obligation to support his entire family, emphasizing the distinct financial roles prescribed in Islam.
Circumstantial Equality: Islamic inheritance is not a rigid, one-size-fits-all formula. It dynamically responds to circumstances. In specific situations, women inherit equal shares, and in some situations she gets more than a man challenging the notion of inherent disparity.
Objection no.4
Wife Obedience:
Islamic teachings emphasize mutual respect and cooperation between spouses, rejecting oppression. The concept of obedience is rooted in companionship and shared decision-making, not subjugation. It's a partnership where both contribute, ensuring a harmonious marital relationship.
Quranic and Hadith References:
a. Quranic Verse (2:187):"They are clothing for you and you are clothing for them." This verse describes the concept of spouses as garments for each other, highlighting the idea of protection, adornment, and mutual care.
b. Hadith:The Hadith literature contains reports emphasizing the importance of kindness, respect, and mutual support within a marriage. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is reported to have said, "The most complete of the believers in faith are those with the best character. And the best of you are those who are best to their women.
Objection no. 5
Domestic Violence: Some argue that Islamic teachings are used to justify or tolerate domestic violence, particularly the controversial interpretation of verse 4:34 in the Quran.
The claim that Islamic teachings justify domestic violence is a misinterpretation that crumbles under scrutiny. Quranic verse 4:34, often misconstrued, calls for measures to address marital discord but cautions against harm. It's a roadmap to reconciliation, not a license for violence. Islam champions compassion, and the Prophet's exemplary behavior emphasizes kindness toward spouses. Those who misuse these teachings betray the essence of Islam, as its core advocates peace within the sanctity of marriage, not a cloak for brutality. So, let's unveil the truth, exposing the distortion and reclaiming the essence of compassion within Islamic teachings on marital relations.
Quran 4:34
Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allāh has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allāh would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance[1] - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them [lightly].[2] But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allāh is ever Exalted and Grand.
Foot note
[1] major rebellion or religious obligations refusal. For example:cheating on the husband.
[2]This final disciplinary measure is more psychological than physical. It may be resorted to only after failure of the first two measures and when it is expected to amend the situation and prevent family breakup; otherwise, it is not acceptable. The Prophet ﷺ (who never struck a woman or a servant) additionally stipulated that it must not be severe or damaging and that the face be avoided.
Objection 6
Child Marriage:
In Islam, the concept of being a teenager doesn't exist. When someone grows up and their body and mind are ready, they are considered adults. This happens around puberty. Now, being an adult means taking on responsibilities. In Islam, when a person is ready( both physically and psychologically matured and are able to take responsibility) they can think about getting married. But here's the important part: both the girl and the boy need to agree to get married. If even one person doesn't want to, the marriage doesn't happen. Also, the girl's guardians (like parents) must agree too. So, everyone involved needs to say yes for the marriage to go ahead.
Objections 7
Limited Travel Without Male Guardian: In some interpretations of Islamic teachings, it is suggested that women should not travel alone without a male guardian (mahram), which is seen as restrictive by some.
Indeed, the requirement for a male guardian (Mahram) during travel is specifically aligned with distant journeys, emphasizing safety during substantial and potentially challenging ventures. It is not intended to restrict women's everyday activities but rather to provide a protective measure during more extended and unfamiliar travels. This nuanced approach ensures that women can move freely within their communities while adding a layer of security for more substantial expeditions. The wisdom behind this guideline is rooted in safeguarding women in situations where the support and protection of a Mahram become particularly crucial, underscoring the Islamic principle of prioritizing well-being over unnecessary risk.
Islamic teachings recognize the importance of flexibility in exceptional circumstances, including emergencies. This flexibility underscores the practical and compassionate nature of Islamic guidelines, allowing for adjustments based on the specific needs and challenges that may arise in different circumstances.
Objection 8
Women cannot sing in public.
In Islam, the prohibition on women singing in public is rooted in the principle of preserving modesty and protecting women from potential harm. Singing is only permissible based on
1What is being sung?
If the lyrics contain haram stuff, then it is impermissible,
2 Whether the music is used. Because because music is haram.
3 Who is singing if a man is singing with this condition, It is ok, but if a woman is singing, then she can only sing in front of maharam man and other women.
If the lyrics promote inappropriate themes, it is considered impermissible.
The distinction between men and women in singing is drawn from the concept of modesty, with women being regarded as precious and needing protection. The term "awrat," derived from "awrah" meaning the most precious and to be protected, is associated with women in Islam.
The guidelines for women's attire and behavior, extend beyond physical covering to include avoiding elements that may attract undue attention or harassment. This encompasses not only clothing but also aspects like, the tone of her voice, avoiding loud perfumes and accessories (sound making high heels and Gungroo)that draw attention. The objective is to cultivate an environment where women are recognized for their virtue and are safeguarded from potential harm or harassment in society.
Objection 9
Women have to bring 4 witnesses to prove she is raped
The claim that Islamic law dismisses requests without four witnesses in rape cases is a misguided accusation. In Islam, the requirement of four witnesses pertains to false accusations of illicit conduct, not instances of sexual assault. The gravity of rape is acknowledged, and Islam empowers women to defend themselves by allowing lethal force against the perpetrator. Furthermore, Islamic law mandates severe punishment for rapists, emphasizing the gravity of the crime. The legal framework in Islam incorporates scientific and investigative evidence, recognizing their significance in establishing the truth. Unlike misconceptions, Islam does not place the burden on the victim to produce witnesses but encourages the use of forensic and detective evidence to ensure justice is served. The Islamic perspective is not a dismissal of rape accusations but a nuanced approach that seeks thorough evidence for just legal proceedings.
Objection 10
Women can not become judge
Islam is more than a set of religious rituals; it serves as a comprehensive guide for life, delineating roles and responsibilities within the societal framework. It establishes a structured family system where men bear the responsibility of being providers, while women excel as homemakers and, significantly, as nurturers shaping the future generation. This exclusive role in raising individuals who become the heroes, scholars, and leaders of society underscores the invaluable contribution of mothers. Embracing hijab and adhering to Sharia rules, women can hold esteemed positions, even serving as chief judges . Islam recognizes inherent differences between men and women, assigning distinct roles that contribute harmoniously to the overall societal fabric. This submission to divine guidance, marked by the principle of "we hear and we obey," reflects a profound commitment to following Allah's rules, even when the reasons behind them are not explicitly provided.
[Note-
The claims suggesting that Islam prohibits women from driving, engaging in sports, or undergoing certain practices are entirely baseless and unrelated to the essence of Islam. Islam stands distinct from cultural practices, and if any cultural element contradicts Islamic principles, it should be abandoned in favor of religious adherence. Islam does not endorse nonsensical cultural norms; it provides a comprehensive and separate framework for life, urging believers to prioritize religious principles over misguided cultural practices. Discerning individuals should be vigilant against false claims that aim to distort the true essence of Islam by conflating it with unrelated cultural impositions.]
Keep going,always have your back 🫶🏻
ReplyDelete